Mamma Mia and The X-Files - October 26th, 2008

Pseudo-intellectual Musings. This blog contains the author's musings on society, culture and tech, along with the odd foodspot review, just to lower the tone and keep her strength up.


Blog For Free!


Archives
Home
2009 March
2009 February
2009 January
2008 December
2008 November
2008 October
2008 September
2008 August
2008 July
2008 June
2008 May

My Links
Timeout Singapore
BookJetty
Rotten Tomatoes
Movie Exclusive
Classical Music Concerts in Asia (searchable)
CNET Asia - Tech
Singapore What's On Today (Angloinfo)
BloggerSG.com
SGBlog.Com
Blog Search Engine

tBlog
My Profile
Send tMail
My tFriends
My Images


Sponsored
Blog


Translate this blog with the buttons below

blogarama.com


Mamma Mia and The X-Files - October 26th, 2008
12.02.08 (11:23 pm)   [edit]

The end of the year is near and Pretensions has completed most of her work commitments and her concert (pictures forthcoming and yes, it went well), so she is finally trying to catch up with her long outstanding blog posts. Here are 2 movies she caught while on the plane from Taiwan to Singapore.

Is there anyone on the planet who hasn't heard of Mamma Mia!, the Abba musical? P saw it several years ago in London during its West End run. She went with about 10 friends and everyone had a great time dancing in the aisles to the unforgettable tunes of  "Dancing Queen", "Gimme, gimme, gimme", "Supertrouper" and other tunes which some readers may be cringing to remember. Well, earlier this year, the powers-that-be in Hollywood decided to convert it into a movie, dressing up its paper-thin plot with an A-list cast including Meryl Streep, Pierce Brosnan, Colin Firth and Julie Walters.

For those not familiar with the movie's excuse for a plot, it centres around Donna (Meryl Streep) an independent fiesty single mother who owns a small rickety hotel on a bucolic Greek island. Donna's daughter Sophie (the nymph-like Amanda Seyfried) is getting married to her long-term greek boyfriend Sky (Dominic Cooper). Sophie embarks on a quest to find out which of Donna's ex-boyfriends (Brosnan, Firth and Stellan Skarsgard) is actually her father. Numerous comedic shenanigans ensue plus enough song-and-dance numbers to stun a Bollywood cast, only rescued from obscurity by the nostalgia of the audience for their favourite Abba numbers.

OK, let it be said that Meryl Streep can definitely sing - she is one very talented lady and P has now added great respect for her singing voice to her awe of Streep's acting talents. Brosnan, on the other hand, should stick to the shower - he'd get booed off the stage of the local karaoke. Julie Walters also can't sing, but is so funny you enjoy her antics anyway. The whole shtick hangs together like a drunken karaoke party actually, full of embarassing older uncles and aunts who should know better, but everyone has lots of fun.

Still there is a certain charm to the whole thing, but why, oh, why, didn't they just leave this as a live production? It was so much better in the theatre and most of the A-list actors might still have their dignity. Watch this on DVD just for the kitsch factor and the chance to dance to "Dancing Queen" one more time in the anonymity of your living room.

To give you the flavour of the movie, enjoy the following 2 videos - "Mamma Mia" and "Does your mother know?". Avoid dancing in public places now!

------------------------- ------------------------

P's second choice The X-Files: I want to believe, whilst also harking back to a past decade but in this case the '90s. P remembers being in university while watching Mulder (David Duchovny) the true believer and Scully (Gillian Anderson) the sceptic in their weekly joust with the supernatural. She was very glad to see that the two actors didn't appear to have aged too much in the intervening decade and a half (unlike P sadly).

The movie begins several years after the two have quite the FBI. Dana Scully is now a full-time staff physician at a Catholic hospital. Fox Mulder is still a fugitive from the law, complete with hermit-like beard. FBI agent Drummy is investigating the mysterious murders of several women and persuades Scully to bring Mulder into the investigation, promising that he will be reinstated in return. Mulder, in turn, recruits Father Joe, a defrocked catholic priest who claims to have visions of the crimes. Various body parts are found, containing traces of an animal tranquilizer. The plot takes various twists and turns from there, taking our heroes through various tests of faith and eventually leading them to the appalling truth behind the murders.

To P, the movie felt like an extended episode of the original X-files, no more no less. It was great for nostalgia value but didn't really advance the X-files mythos one iota. Even Scully's son was barely referred to and the main plot strand felt somewhat hackneyed and unimportant. There were some great chilling moments during the move, but sadly they didn't really lead to a decent denouement. The chemistry between Mulder and Scully is still great, but it's not really enough to carry even fans through a (nearly) two hour movie.

Don't get P wrong, the movie wasn't bad, but it could have been much better. Here's a clip which might at least illustrate the returning Mulder/Scully relationship.

 


posted by: OldSchool (reply)
post date: 12.02.08 (8:29 am)

Mamma Mia! I loved the Musical which I saw in NY on Broadway several times. Clever & lighthearted fun with songs you already know. I really enjoyed it each and every time.

I could not bring myself to see the movie. I just could not imagine it working as a movie and it sounds like from reviews (such as yours) that I was right. I don't know if I will ever see it.

I do highly recommend the Musical Show if anyone gets the chance to see it in NY or by a touring company.



posted by: alaskawildflowers (reply)
post date: 12.02.08 (9:19 am)

I have to say, I loved the movie! Yes, the plot was thin, but the laugh factor was high! And I liked the fact that Pierce Brosnan had the cojones to actually let anyone else hear his voice-- it humanized him. Meryl Streep is always good fun, and it's nice to enjoy her in a movie that doesn't wrench your heart out. I loved the number the 3 women did at the end in their extremely campy bellbottomed outfits-- I live in a very small town, and some people did get up and dance at the end; I was laughing too hard.



posted by: pretensions (reply)
post date: 12.03.08 (6:22 am)

Reply to: OldSchool

Hi OS, I think the DVD's now available and it might be worth renting for the curiousity value. I much prefer the live version 'tho. There some magic there that the movie just can't quite capture....




posted by: pretensions (reply)
post date: 12.03.08 (6:24 am)

Reply to: alaskawildflowers

Yes, I loved that too - the Supertrouper number was great! Like I said, it's all kind of drunken karaoke kitsch but there's a lot of fun in that too, sometimes!

Your Name:


Your Comment:


The author of this blog lives in Singapore and travels extensively to maintain her pretensions of culture and other bright shiny things.

Comments always welcome!

Please note that this blog is now mirrored at http://pretensions.0fees.net/.

For a snazzier design, up-to-date table of contents and a working RSS feed, please visit Pretension's self-hosted mirror, running on Wordpress.

Pretensions Feed

Table of Contents